Mar 20, 2014

Posted by in Reviews | 2 Comments

Anne Reviews: Oracle of Philadelphia by Elizabeth Corrigan (Earthbound Angels #1)

oracleofphiladelphia3 star

Urban Fantasy
March 20 2013
eBook
222 pages
Red Adept Publishing
Received from publisher

Kick Ass Chick – Carrie

From Goodreads –
Carrie works at a diner in South Philadelphia, dispensing advice to humans and angels wise enough to seek her counsel. But there are some problems that even the best advice can’t solve.

Her latest supplicant, Sebastian, is unique among those who have sought her aid. He sold his soul to a demon in exchange for his sister’s life, but his heart remains pure.

Carrie has lived for millennia with the knowledge that her immortality is due to the suffering of others, and she cannot bear to see another good man damned when it is within her power to prevent it.

In order to renegotiate his contract, Carrie must travel into the depths of hell and parley with the demons that control its pathways. As the cost of her journey rises, Carrie must determine how much she is willing to sacrifice to save one good soul.

———-

Oracle of Philadelphia is the first book in the Earthbound Angels series, a new urban fantasy series by Elizabeth Corrigan.  Well, let’s start by admitting I often have trouble starting a new series.  Urban Fantasy is harder than romance because, well, there isn’t always a romance plot or hot sex.  So why do I read and love urban fantasy?  The primary reasons are the characters, some kind of mystery / suspense / action plot,  clever world building and humor.

So beginning with the characters, Carrie is the main focus and the most known to us in this story.  Her past is long and her starting moment is horrible.  I didn’t need to keep hearing parts of it throughout the book.  For the plot maybe I did, but no.  She is strong and capable by necessity with little or no help or support system in life.

Carrie owns a diner and we see only bits of her employees, but they don’t seem very real to me.   Her best friend is Bedlam, a chaos demon.  He can be unpredictable but is a real friend.  He’s more well developed with some history and insight available on him.  Gabriel is her “crush” but I didn’t feel him other than a bright light she was happy to see. I need more from him.

The other characters, even Sebastian, who is a focus for Carrie, are not clear enough for me to care about them.  Maybe he was too good to be true?

The world building was interesting. It carried me on through the story and I enjoyed it.  I normally don’t prefer stories with angels and demons as much as some other supernatural, but this was surprisingly good and kept me reading.  When they border on religious themes, I have serious trouble.  This just had rules and authorities I disliked.  Some things weren’t logical or fair.  I prefer when people are smart or work hard, they can figure things out and succeed.  This world wasn’t quite that simple.

There was a bit of humor and a possibility of romance.  I freely admit those things are important to me and the lack of them being stronger in this book made it less appealing to me.  These are the things which make me feel the most.

The other big thing is the plot.  I’ll reiterate, I prefer the main characters to be smart or to learn or work hard, to triumph.  This was more bumbling around by trial and error to hopefully get the desired outcome.  It was brave and honorable of Carrie but not very smart.  I wanted it to be a little more smart.  I didn’t appreciate Gabriel’s reaction to the situation either.

Oracle of Philadelphia was a good book with an interesting world; it kept my attention.  I don’t feel like it engaged my emotions very fully, though.   The next book, Raising Chaos, is just out and focuses on Bedlam.  It makes sense based on the plot of this story but I’d rather learn more about Gabriel or one of the others.   So I may wait and see what the focus of the third book is before I read further in this series.

3 stars

anne signature

  1. Great review Anne! I love your honesty and I definitely have been in the place of waiting till future installments come out before proceeding with a series. Sometimes it’s just easier to focus on other books that you feel you’ll really enjoy instead of focusing on books that don’t really appeal to you as much. I will say that the cover of this book is pretty darn awesome!

  2. I agree completely with your review. My biggest problem with this book was that it felt too religiously charged. I like my angels and all, but I prefer them like the angels in Nalini Singh’s Guilt Hunter series.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *